In corporate finance, it is the hurdle rate on investments, an optimizing tool for capital structure and a divining rod for dividends. Openreach prepares to retire copper network financial times. The cost of capital is determined by computing the costs of various. This cost of capital therefore provides a good benchmark of the return that bts shareholders require. Ofcoms approach to risk in the assessment of the cost of. Ofcoms approach to risk in the assessment of the cost of capital. The opportunity cost of capital article pdf available in inquiry. Calculate firms weighted average cost of capital 5. Ofcom notes that openreachs returns from wholesale isdn30 services are well above its weighted average cost of capital and that it is appropriate to impose an rpix control. Review of bt network charge controls 3 cost modelling 1. The socalled openreach wacc must be conceived of, calculated as and applied as the wacc for copper access services activities i. Introduction john earwaker thursday 28 february 2019 cost of capital conference. Greater the uncertainty about future financing needs.
The estimated cost of capital for broadcast transmission. Openreach decision is an upgrade for all as long as ofcom. The latest cost estimates for this are close to ofcom s arguably more optimistic model of fttp deployment, which indicated that the capital expenditure needed to do fttp for the first c. Relevance of cost of capital marketing sales costs customer care rtbilling depreciation operating costs, etc. Bt and uk telecoms equity beta against ftse all share. For example, when estimating the cost of capital on behalf of bt openreach, oxera argued in august 2008 that there have been clear and significant negative developments in capital markets over the past year, which have resulted in an increase in the cost of raising.
The quarters results to the end of june 2016 have been published by bt and for those comparing with previous quarters results they need to remember that the impact of the ee customer base has to be factored in. Openreach will be required to fix 88pc of faults within two days, up from 80pc today. A summary of the relevant parameters underpinning wacc and a comparison of bt and ofcom is shown in the two tables below which respectively give detail on the computation of the central estimates and the ranges. Llu and wlr and not include the cost of capital of openreach s other businesses such as nga we consider the risk free rate is better set at 1. In corporate finance, it is the hurdle rate on investments, an optimizing. Network rails allowed return prepared for orr 1 december 2011. Aswath damodaran april 2016 abstract new york university. Again, whilst new build residential developments constitute a small part of openreachs activities, it is striking that capital expenditure before inflation. It is intended to inform orrs thinking as regards the allowed return to factor into the indicative cp5 revenue requirement calculations that orr will be providing to ministers in early 2012. Access charge controls and estimated cost of capital. We discussed the change control notification report with bt. Would an independent openreach be able to afford this investment without bt as a parent. Current cost financial statements 2014 including openreach. Accordingly openreach s cost of capital should be set towards the upper limit of this range, at 12.
As a result, certain market metrics that contribute to estimates of bts cost of capital have fallen resulting in lower estimates of bts cost of capital this time around. Chapter 14 the cost of capital texas tech university. Accordingly, ofcom has indicated that if it regulates openreach fibre services it will add a margin to compensate for this risk. We continue to make progress on the bt modernisation agenda, delivering over. Openreach decision is an upgrade for all as long as ofcom gets sums right. Bt unhappy with new openreach pricing friday, may 22, 2009 2. Nov 29, 2016 vodafone uk believes ofcoms move to enforce the legal separation of openreach from bt is required as a new report from frontier economics, a leading economic consultancy, reveals that bts excess profit increased by 28% to more than. Meanwhile, bt would gain greater investment certainty, a lower cost of capital at openreach and a more efficient capital structure. Ofcom proposals for charge controls on openreach with respect. Ofcom also said it would tighten rules on repairs and installations. Business and enterprise select committee home ofcom.
Openreach is a functional division of telecommunications company bt plc, that maintains the telephone cables, ducts, cabinets and exchanges that connect nearly all homes and businesses in the united kingdom to the national broadband and telephone network. Periodically ofcom determines the appropriate cost of capital for given charge controls as a weighted average cost of capital wacc. Updating the cost of capital for the transmission price. Critique of oxeras report for the nma on the cost of capital. Ofcoms approach to risk in the assessment of the cost of capital pdf, 202. Bts beta are all important inputs in estimating any companys wacc. Ofcom has released new price controls on bt openreach this morning which define how the division can charge for access to the local loop including mpf metallic path facility. Annex b bts comments on the cost of capital home ofcom. This month ofcom will flesh out its plans to push through enhanced functional separation of openreach after identifying major failings with bt in. Openreach charges wlr new connection new conections takeover from other cp bt retail costs for wlr 201112 new line.
The cost of capital is the cost of a firms debt and equity funds, or the required rate of return on a portfolio of the companys existing securities. Ofcoms other two main prescriptions for openreach will have to pass a realworld test. Physical infrastructure access pia provides the ability for you to share openreachs duct and pole infrastructure in our access network so that you may deploy your next generation access networks in order to offer superfast broadband and telephony services to your customers. The latest cost estimates for this are close to ofcoms arguably more optimistic model of fttp deployment, which indicated that the capital expenditure needed to do fttp for the first c. Cost of capital annual update report the uk regulators network. The differences are important, but would legal separation change bts and openreachs behaviour to the degree desired by ofcom. Ofcoms proposal equates to legal separation, as defined by. First network rails allowed return economics 1 december 2011. Legal separation means that openreach would become a whollyowned subsidiary of bt with separate governance, and strategic and. The differences are important, but would legal separation change bts and openreachs behaviour to the. Greater the separation between managers and stockholders greater the benefit 2. Jan 24, 2011 relevance of cost of capital marketing sales costs customer care rtbilling depreciation operating costs, etc. To counter these perceived market weaknesses, ofcom proposed that openreach should be established as a separate limited company, within the bt group but with various behavioural constraints built in to its articles of association 10 ofcom, 2016b. Aug 09, 2019 accordingly, ofcom has indicated that if it regulates openreach fibre services it will add a margin to compensate for this risk.
In april 2015, ofcom announced that telephone companies would have to provide customers with a set charge for the cost of calling numbers starting 084, 087 and 09. It was established in 2006 following an agreement between bt and the uks telecoms. The market cost of capital, the rate allowed by the regulator and the regulated firms approach to capital budgeting are important influences on the firms investment behaviour. In particular bts pension fund obligations are likely to lead to the cost of capital for the bt group as a whole being significantly higher than for the operating assets. Feb 25, 2016 openreach decision is an upgrade for all as long as ofcom gets sums right. Appendix b1 the cost of capital for openreach ofcom.
Uk telco regulation cannot work to incentivise fibre build as. Openreach announced a further 29 locations in its build plan to reach 4m premises by march 2021, and we continue to make positive progress with government and ofcom on the enablers to stimulate further investment in full fibre. This submission is provided by openreach, a functionally separate. In ofcoms proposal this is through the articles of association of openreach, whilst in bts proposal it is through those of the bt group. Ofcom has released new price controls on bt openreach this morning which define how the division can charge for access to the local loop including mpf metallic path facility and smpf shared metallic path facility services.
Since ofcom last estimated bt and openreach s cost of capital in 2009, market economies have begun to emerge from the effect of the credit crisis. In its 2016 bmcr statement, ofcom decided to move from its previous twoway. Cost of capital conference introduction john earwaker. Ofcom s current proposals do not give investors a fair return 5. The cost of equity can be computed using the capital asset pricing model capm or the arbitrage pricing theory apt model.
The estimated cost of capital for broadcast transmission 2015. Openreach an obligation to treat all customers equally. Section 4 of the discussion document outlines openreachs nominal capital expenditure over the last decade which has remained constant over the period ranging from. Ofcoms strategy7 is to promote the wide and extensive. Bt financials show openreach has a 24% gea product penetration rate thursday, july 28, 2016 10. Based on oxeras assessment, an appropriate range for bts cost of capital for the. Detailed documentation for the model is included in this consultation document at annex 6 and the approach is also explained in section 4.
Ofcom s strategy7 is to promote the wide and extensive. The swiss army knife of finance aswath damodaran april 2016 abstract there is no number in finance that is used in more places or in more contexts than the cost of capital. Aug 05, 2019 the latest cost estimates for this are close to ofcoms arguably more optimistic model of fttp deployment, which indicated that the capital expenditure needed to do fttp for the first c. Following these discussions, bt decided not to implement one of its proposed changes described in the. Upd7 ofcom confirm no openreach split from bt, but change is. Ofcom is investigating whether it should adjust the cost of capital element of its wholesale charge calculations the return required on investments and assets so ofcom can set charge controls to accommodate the impact of the pension fund on bts risk. Genuine openreach independence from bt could unlock and accelerate the development of fixed broadband investment, innovation and competition to the benefit of uk consumers and businesses. Under such smp conditions bt is required to publish with the audited regulatory financial. Calculate the aftertax cost of debt, preferred stock, and common equity. Fig 1 shows that leverage is only 2x on the rest of bt if openreach is levered to 60% of rab, including the pension deficit. Bt financials show openreach has a 24% gea product. Fixing openreachs performance issues may require additional investment. Again, we believe the commission should be cautious adopting specific elements of an overseas regulatory framework in isolation. Mar 21, 2019 openreach, the company that controls the uks telecoms infrastructure, has opened a consultation with the broadband industry to agree a framework to retire the countrys copper network so it.
Ofcom helpfully identifies the asset beta of openreach, a business closely comparable to chorus even if it. The streamlining of these charges must be printed in each customers contract and monthly bills. Openreach, the company that controls the uks telecoms infrastructure, has opened a consultation with the broadband industry to agree a framework to. Ofcom s proposal equates to legal separation, as defined by. The relationship between bt profitability and charge controls. Ofcom proposes a price cap of rpi8% to rpi12% for the main basket of isdn30 rentals and connections. Annex a contents executive summary 5 1 purpose of the report 12 2 the uks approach to the fixed broadband market 15 2. The cost of capital estimation process the cost of capital for a company is the cost of raising an additional dollar of capital. Cost of capital in the telco industry linkedin slideshare. Detailed documentation for the model is included in this consultation document at annex 6 and the approach is. As with bt, the low cost of capital for openreach on its own will mirror the lower cost of capital for transco and the risky stuff, like football rights, can be run by managers who are good at highrisk entrepreneurial activities. We have updated our analysis since the june 2017 response to reflect ofcom s latest proposals all other things being equal. These proposals would replace the 2005 undertakings with a less cumbersome and more effective regime, powered primarily by company law. Wholesaleproduct cost of capital 1020% cost of capital 1525% cost of capital plays a substantial role in the.
1314 1469 568 77 1314 1184 881 1382 421 1143 10 1157 1019 187 916 1031 396 254 241 336 973 874 369 722 34 694 1213 1030 241 422 419 1170 1344 315 356 443 967 1497 1279 1106 785 294 1470